Book Summary - Applied Elite Theory (Neema Parvini)

Summary: Parvini’s primary objective is to dismantle the idea that "the people" can ever be a sovereign political actor. In Applied Elite Theory, he argues that what we perceive as "populism"—from the MAGA movement to the Yellow Vests—is fundamentally misunderstood by both its supporters and its detractors.


1. Applied Elite Theory (Neema Parvini)

[Google Gemini summary]

This book acts as the practical "final act" in a trilogy that includes The Populist Delusion (theory) and The Prophets of Doom (history). It applies the "cold realism" of the Italian Elite School to the specific political events of the 2020s.

1. The Core Thesis: "The Populist Delusion" in Practice

Parvini’s primary objective is to dismantle the idea that "the people" can ever be a sovereign political actor. In Applied Elite Theory, he argues that what we perceive as "populism"—from the MAGA movement to the Yellow Vests—is fundamentally misunderstood by both its supporters and its detractors.

  • The Iron Law of Oligarchy: Parvini leans heavily on Robert Michels to argue that all organizations, no matter how democratic their start, inevitably become oligarchies.

  • Top-Down Reality: Political change never moves from the bottom up. It is always a result of a counter-elite successfully challenging an incumbent elite, usually by organizing the "masses" as a blunt instrument.

  • The Delusion: The "delusion" is the belief that voting or protesting can change the structural nature of power. Parvini argues that "power never flows upward; it is always exercised by an organized minority."

2. Part I: The American Context – The Trump Era as a Case Study

Parvini dedicates significant space to analyzing the 2016–2024 American political cycle through the lens of Vilfredo Pareto and James Burnham.

The Failure of the "Lion"

Parvini uses Pareto’s distinction between "Lions" (elites who use force and tradition) and "Foxes" (elites who use cunning, finance, and bureaucracy).

  • Trump was perceived as a "Lion" by a base that wanted a restoration of traditional sovereignty.

  • However, Parvini argues Trump failed because he attempted to lead without an alternative bureaucracy. He had the "will" of the people but lacked the "logistical power" of an organized counter-elite.

Elite Overproduction and Capture

Using Peter Turchin’s theories, Parvini discusses Elite Overproduction. America produces too many degree-holding "aspirant elites" for too few positions of real power. This creates a volatile class of "counter-elites" who use populist rhetoric not to help the poor, but to clear a path for their own advancement.

  • Capture: Parvini shows how movements like "The Squad" or "MAGA" are eventually captured by the "Iron Law of Oligarchy." They become incorporated into the very system they intended to disrupt, eventually serving the interests of the party leadership (the "Ancient Leaders").

3. Part II: The British Context – The Managerial State

In the UK section, Parvini focuses on the transition from traditional parliamentary politics to a Managerial State, heavily citing Samuel Francis and Bertrand de Jouvenel.

The Blairite Synthesis

Parvini argues that the "regime" in Britain did not change when the Conservatives took over in 2010. Instead, he posits that Tony Blair’s "Managerial Revolution" was so total that the Conservative Party simply became a "managerial" entity in a blue tie.

  • The Blob: He describes the "civil service-NGO-media" complex as the true sovereign.

  • Hollow Parties: Political parties in the UK are no longer mass-membership organizations with distinct ideologies; they are shells used by the managerial class to rotate personnel.

Anarcho-Tyranny

Parvini applies Samuel Francis’s concept of Anarcho-Tyranny to modern Britain. This is a state where:

  1. Anarchy: The state fails to perform basic functions (securing borders, stopping street crime).

  2. Tyranny: The state hyper-regulates the law-abiding middle class (speech laws, tax audits, "hate crime" monitoring).

  • This creates a "high-low" squeeze where the elites use the "underclass" or "marginalized groups" as a weapon against the "middle-class" (the traditional source of counter-elites).

4. Part III: The Global "Vibe Shift" and Digital Realism

The final third of the book deals with the 2020s "Vibe Shift" and the role of the internet in elite formation.

The Dissident Right and "Containment"

Parvini offers a self-critique and a critique of the "Dissident Right." He warns that even "radical" online spaces can become a form of containment.

  • If a movement does not result in the formation of a disciplined, organized minority capable of seizing institutional levers, it is merely "entertainment" for the regime.

  • The Myth of the "Great Reset": While acknowledging globalist ambitions, Parvini uses Elite Theory to argue that these groups are often less competent and more prone to internal "elite infighting" than conspiracy theorists believe.

The "High-Mid-Low" Model

Parvini utilizes Jouvenel’s model of power:

  • The High (The State/Elites): Seek to expand power.

  • The Mid (The Aristocracy/Middle Class/Local Power): The only real threat to the High.

  • The Low (The Masses): Used as pawns.

    The "High" always tries to bypass the "Mid" by appealing directly to the "Low" (populism), promising them gifts to destroy the "Mid’s" independence.

5. Practical Applications: How to "Ride the Tiger"

Parvini concludes with advice for those who recognize these patterns, drawing from Julius Evola.

  • Disillusioned Realism: The first step is to stop believing that "one more election" will fix a structural civilizational decay.

  • Build Parallel Structures: If power is organization, then the only response is to organize. However, he remains skeptical of mass movements, favoring small, high-competence "cadres."

  • Wait for the Breaking Point: He suggests that the current managerial elite is suffering from competence crisis. Like Joseph Tainter’s theory of "diminishing returns on complexity," the current system is becoming too complex and expensive to maintain.

Summary Table: Key Thinkers in Applied Elite Theory

ThinkerConcept AppliedParvini’s Application
Gaetano MoscaThe Ruling ClassPolitics is always the rule of the organized minority.
Vilfredo ParetoLions vs. FoxesThe West is ruled by "Foxes" (bureaucrats) who lack the "Lion" (will to protect).
Robert MichelsIron Law of OligarchyWhy populist parties always betray their voters.
Samuel FrancisAnarcho-TyrannyThe state punishing the innocent while ignoring the guilty.
James BurnhamManagerial RevolutionThe shift of power from owners/voters to managers/technocrats.
Peter TurchinElite OverproductionWhy we have so much civil unrest among the educated class.

Conclusion: The End of the "Long 1990s"

Parvini views the 2020s as the definitive end of the liberal-democratic consensus. Applied Elite Theory serves as a manual for understanding a world where "democracy" is a formal ritual masking an intense struggle between decaying managerial elites and nascent, disorganized counter-elites.

Popular posts from this blog

Book Summary - The Value of Everything: Making and Taking in the Global Economy (Mariana Mazzucato)

Image
Summary : "A critique of modern capitalist economies, arguing that the confusion between value creation (making) and value extraction (taking) is the root cause of today's widening inequality, financial instability, and slow innovation. Mazzucato contends that over the last few decades, the way economists define, measure, and reward value has fundamentally changed, allowing rent-seeking activities to masquerade as wealth creation. This shift has led to massive rewards for those who merely extract wealth from the system, while the true collective creators of value—including the state, workers, and long-term investors—are increasingly undervalued and under-compensated." The book proposes that if we are to successfully reform capitalism and steer the global economy toward sustainable, inclusive, and innovation-led growth, we must first reignite the long-dormant debate about what economic value truly is, and who, precisely, creates it. Key Ideas : Value creation vs extraction...
Read more

Article Commentary: There is no evidence NDIS therapies help kids thrive

Image
Summary : The purpose of this article is not debating evidence for NDIS-funded therapies, it's about ever-increasing government spending that is wasteful, low-value and exposed to fraud:  "It is no coincidence that Australia’s sluggish productivity, real wages and living standards coincided with massive amounts of taxpayer money being pumped into the now $52 billion National Disability Insurance Scheme and other social welfare programs over the past decade."
Read more

How much of my DIY superannuation cash returns are being extracted by super funds?

Image
Problem : Australians managing their own super may lose ~1-3% of their interest on cash in their superannuation transaction accounts compared to the minimum super funds are making on it (benchmarked by the RBA Cash Rate). Interest rates well under 1% are not uncommon for SMSF or DIY Super. By eliminating the value of risk-free cash returns, the finance industry forces people into fee-extracting and unnecessarily high-risk or fraud-exposed investments. Key Ideas : Wealth Extraction; Financial Repression; Negative Real Rates (aka Stealth Tax). Rationale : Australians employees are forced to have 12% of their wages paid into super. If saving in at-call cash outside of super they could get returns ~0.5-1% higher than the RBA Cash Rate. E.g. Macquarie offers 4.25% with the RBA rate at 3.6%. Solution : Force federal politicians to require all super funds to pay a minimum interest rate on cash benchmarked to the RBA Cash Rate (or relevant proxy like BBSW). See prior reforms  here . Rew...
Read more